Flipping the Script: Why the “Old” Food Pyramid is Making Us Sick (And What to Eat Instead)
By Mark G. Agresti, MD
Sitting here in my office on the Intracoastal Waterway, watching the boats drift past the Breakers Hotel golf course, I often think about the “hidden” factors that bring patients into my care. We talk about trauma, anxiety, and depression—but we rarely talk enough about what is on our plates.
For decades, we were sold a lie. The traditional “Food Pyramid” told us to load up on 6–11 servings of bread, cereal, and pasta every day. The result? An epidemic of obesity, heart disease, and chronic inflammation that destroys not just the body, but the brain.
At Mark G. Agresti, MD, LLC, I believe in treating the root cause. It is time to turn the pyramid upside down.
The Failed Experiment: Why Carbs Are Killing Us
The old pyramid placed complex carbohydrates—cereals, enriched wheat flour, and pastas—at the foundation. We now know that this was a mistake.
• The Heart Disease Myth: We were told fat causes heart disease. The data now suggests that inflammation caused by high-sugar, high-carb diets is the real culprit.
• The Wheat Problem: Modern “enriched” wheat flour spikes your blood sugar faster than table sugar. This insulin spike leads to fat storage and systemic inflammation.
The “New” Agresti Pyramid: A Carnivore-leaning Approach
If we look at human evolution, our bodies were designed to thrive on nutrient-dense proteins and fats, not processed grains. Here is how your plate should look:
Level 1: The Foundation (Eat Freely)
The bottom of the pyramid should be animal protein and healthy fats. These provide the essential amino acids and cholesterol your brain needs to function.
• Proteins: Beef, pork, poultry, chicken, and wild-caught fish.
• Fats: Butter, cheese, tallow, and eggs (yolks included!). Do not fear saturated fat; it is the building block of your hormones.
Level 2: Vegetables
Organic, low-starch vegetables that provide fiber and micronutrients without the massive insulin spike.
Level 3: Fruits (In Moderation)
Fruit is nature’s candy. It offers vitamins, but it is still sugar (fructose). Stick to berries and lower-glycemic options.
Level 4: The Tiny Top (Natural Sweeteners)
White sugar should be eliminated. If you need sweetness, use trace amounts of dates, honey, or maple syrup. These contain minerals that white sugar lacks.
The Toxic “No-Go” List: What to Avoid at All Costs
The modern American diet is a minefield of chemicals. To protect your mental and physical health, you must become a label detective.
1. The Seed Oil Trap
Industrial seed oils (Canola, Soybean, Corn, Sunflower) are highly processed and high in Omega-6 fatty acids, which drive inflammation. Eliminate them. Cook with butter, ghee, or coconut oil instead.
2. The “Dirty Dozen” and Pesticides
Non-organic produce is often sprayed with herbicides and pesticides like Glyphosate (Roundup). The Environmental Working Group’s “Dirty Dozen” (including strawberries, spinach, and kale) act like sponges for these poisons. Always buy organic for these items.
3. Bioengineered Foods & “Campbell’s Soup” Syndrome
Major food corporations, like Campbell’s and others, often rely on bioengineered (GMO) ingredients to cut costs. Our bodies are not evolutionarily designed to process these genetically altered foods. When you eat “Franken-food,” your immune system may react as if it’s under attack.
4. The Chemical Cocktail
• Preservatives: Watch out for Sodium Phosphate and Sodium Benzoate. These additives extend shelf life but are linked to hyperactivity and cellular damage.
• Forever Chemicals (PFAS): found in fast-food wrappers and water, these chemicals never break down in the body and disrupt hormones.
• Microplastics: Found increasingly in sea salts and seafood.
• Hidden Contaminants: Even your morning routine isn’t safe. Non-organic coffee and chocolate are often high in mold toxins and heavy metals.
Hydration: The Forgotten Nutrient
None of this works if you are dehydrated. Water is the medium in which all metabolic processes happen. Filter your water to avoid the fluoride and chlorine, but drink plenty of it.
Why This Matters for Psychiatry
You cannot have a healthy mind in an inflamed body. If you are struggling with brain fog, anxiety, or treatment-resistant depression, your diet might be the missing puzzle piece.
Come See Us in Palm Beach
Changing your lifestyle is hard, but you don’t have to do it alone. My practice is a sanctuary where we look at the whole picture.
Come sit in our waiting room, enjoy the view of the Intracoastal, and say hello to Bella, my Boykin Spaniel. She’s the heart of our office and a great reminder to live in the moment!
Call us today: 561-744-0744
Visit: drmarkagresti.com
Location: 44 Coconut Row, M 202, Palm Beach, FL 33480
We offer next-day appointments to get you started on the path to health immediately.
#TheNewFoodPyramid #CarnivoreDiet #DrMarkAgresti #MarkAgrestiMD #PalmBeachPsychiatrist #KetoLifestyle #NoSeedOils #CleanEating #MentalHealthAwareness #GutBrainAxis #GlyphosateFree #OrganicLiving #DirtyDozen #BioengineeredFoods #WestPalmBeach #Intracoastal #CocoanutRow #BellaTheDog #BoykinSpaniel #HolisticHealth #Psychiatry #HeartHealth #InflammationRelief